GummyBear

This song finds Mini Mansions frontman Michael Shuman reflecting on the breakdown of his relationship with his fiancée. He explained to Billboard: "I tried to shape and mold someone, my GummyBear, who ultimately wasn't the person for me, no matter how bad I wanted them to be."

The Guy Walks Into a Bar... album is informed by the relationship Shuman had with his fiancée. He wrote a series of different songs about their romance in real time, from the beginning as they fell in love to the process of breaking up.